Protocol Buffers/gRPC Codegen Integration Into .NET Build

The Grpc.Tools NuGet package provides C# tooling support for generating C# code from .proto files in .csproj projects:

• It contains protocol buffers compiler and gRPC plugin to generate C# code.
• It can be used in building both grpc-dotnet projects and legacy c-core C# projects.

Using Grpc.Tools in .csproj files is described below. Other packages providing the runtime libraries for gRPC are described elsewhere.

Getting Started

The package Grpc.Tools is used automatically to generate the C# code for protocol buffer messages and gRPC service stubs from .proto files. These files:

• are generated on an as-needed basis each time the project is built.
• aren't added to the project or checked into source control.
• are a build artifact usually contained in the obj directory.

This package is optional. You may instead choose to generate the C# source files from .proto files by running the protoc compiler manually or from a script. However this package helps to simplify generating the C# source files by integrating the code generation into the build process. It can be used when building both the server and client projects, and by both c-core C# projects and grpc-dotnet projects:

• The Grpc.AspNetCore metapackage already includes a reference to Grpc.Tools.
• gRPC for .NET client projects and projects using Grpc.Core need to reference Grpc.Tools explicity if you want code generation for those projects

Grpc.Tools is only used at build-time and has no runtime components. It should be marked with PrivateAssets="All" to prevent it from being included at runtime, e.g.

<PackageReference Include="Grpc.Tools" Version="2.50.0">
  <IncludeAssets>runtime; build; native; contentfiles; analyzers; buildtransitive</IncludeAssets>
  <PrivateAssets>all</PrivateAssets>
</PackageReference>

Support is provided for the following platforms:

• Windows (x86, x64, and arm64 via using the x86 binaries)
• MacOS (x64 and arm64 via using the x64 binaries)
• Linux (x86, x64, and arm64)

Adding .proto files to a project

To add .proto files to a project edit the project’s .csproj file and add an item group with a <Protobuf> element that refers to the .proto file, e.g.

<ItemGroup>
    <Protobuf Include="Protos\greet.proto" />
</ItemGroup>

Wildcards can be used to select several .proto files, e.g.

<ItemGroup>
    <Protobuf Include="**\*.proto" />
</ItemGroup>

By default, a <Protobuf> reference generates gRPC client and a service base class from the service definitions in the .proto files. The GrpcServices attribute can be used to limit C# asset generation. See the reference section below for all options. E.g. to only generate client code:

<ItemGroup>
    <Protobuf Include="Protos\greet.proto" GrpcServices="Client" />
</ItemGroup>

For .proto files that are outside of the project directory a link can be added so that the files are visible in Visual Studio. E.g.

<ItemGroup>
   <Protobuf Include="..\Proto\aggregate.proto" GrpcServices="Client" Link="Protos\aggregate.proto"/>
   <Protobuf Include="..\Proto\greet.proto" GrpcServices="None" Link="Protos\greet.proto"/>
   <Protobuf Include="..\Proto\count.proto" GrpcServices="None" Link="Protos\count.proto"/>
</ItemGroup>

For more examples see the example project files in GitHub: https://github.com/grpc/grpc-dotnet/tree/master/examples

Reference

Protobuf item metadata reference

The following metadata are recognized on the <Protobuf> items.

Name	Default	Value	Synopsis
Access	public	public, internal	Generated class access
AdditionalProtocArguments		arbitrary cmdline arguments	Extra command line flags passed to protoc command. To specify multiple arguments use semi-colons (;) to separate them. See example below
ProtoCompile	true	true, false	If false, don't invoke protoc to generate code.
ProtoRoot	See notes	A directory	Common root for set of files
CompileOutputs	true	true, false	If false, C# code will be generated, but it won't be included in the C# build.
OutputDir	See notes	A directory	Directory for generated C# files with protobuf messages
OutputOptions		arbitrary options	Extra options passed to C# codegen as --csharp_opt=opt1,opt2
GrpcOutputDir	See notes	A directory	Directory for generated gRPC stubs
GrpcOutputOptions		arbitrary options	Extra options passed to gRPC codegen as --grpc_opt=opt1,opt2
GrpcServices	Both	None, Client, Server, Both	Generated gRPC stubs
AdditionalImportDirs	See notes	Directories	Specify additional directories in which to search for imports .proto files

Notes

• ProtoRoot
  For files inside the project directory or its subdirectories, ProtoRoot is set by default to the project directory.

  For files outside of the project directory, the value is set to the file's containing directory name, individually per file. If you include a subtree of .proto files that lies outside of the project directory, you need to set ProtoRoot. There is an example of this below. The path in this variable is relative to the project directory.

• OutputDir
  The default value is the value of the property Protobuf_OutputPath. This property, in turn, unless you set it in your project, will be set to the value of the standard MSBuild property IntermediateOutputPath, which points to the location of compilation object outputs, such as "obj/Release/netstandard1.5/". The path in this property is considered relative to the project directory.

• GrpcOutputDir
  Unless explicitly set, will follow OutputDir for any given file.

• Access
  Sets generated class access on both generated message and gRPC stub classes.

• AdditionalProtocArguments Pass additional commandline arguments to the protoc command being invoked. Normally this option should not be used, but it exists for scenarios when you need to pass otherwise unsupported (e.g. experimental) flags to protocol buffer compiler.

• OutputOptions Pass additional C# code generation options to protoc in the form --csharp_opt=opt1,opt2. See C#-specific options for possible values.

• GrpcOutputOptions Pass additional options to the grpc_csharp_plugin in form of the --grpc_opt flag. Normally this option should not be used as its values are already controlled by Access and GrpcServices metadata, but it might be useful in situations where you want to explicitly pass some otherwise unsupported (e.g. experimental) options to the grpc_csharp_plugin.

• AdditionalImportDirs Specify additional directories in which to search for imports in .proto files. The directories are searched in the order given. You may specify directories outside of the project directory. The directories are passed to the protoc code generator via the -I/--proto_path option together with Protobuf_StandardImportsPath and ProtoRoot directories.

Specifying multiple values in properties

Some properties allow you to specify multiple values in a list. The items in a list need to be separated by semi-colons (;). This is the syntax that MsBuild uses for lists.

The properties that can have lists of items are: OutputOptions, AdditionalProtocArguments, GrpcOutputOptions, AdditionalImportDirs

Example: to specify two additional arguments: --plugin=protoc-gen-myplugin=D:\myplugin.exe --myplugin_out=.

  <ItemGroup>
    <Protobuf Include="proto_root/**/*.proto" ProtoRoot="proto_root"
              OutputDir="%(RelativeDir)" CompileOutputs="false"
              AdditionalProtocArguments="--plugin=protoc-gen-myplugin=D:\myplugin.exe;--myplugin_out=." />
  </ItemGroup>

grpc_csharp_plugin command line options

Under the hood, the Grpc.Tools build integration invokes the protoc and grpc_csharp_plugin binaries to perform code generation. Here is an overview of the available grpc_csharp_plugin options:

Name	Default	Synopsis
no_client	off	Don't generate the client stub
no_server	off	Don't generate the server-side stub
internal_access	off	Generate classes with “internal” visibility

Note that the protocol buffer compiler has a special commandline syntax for plugin options. Example:

protoc --plugin=protoc-gen-grpc=grpc_csharp_plugin --csharp_out=OUT_DIR \
    --grpc_out=OUT_DIR --grpc_opt=lite_client,no_server \
    -I INCLUDE_DIR foo.proto

Environment Variables

Environment variables can be set to change the behavior of Grpc.Tools - setting the CPU architecture or operating system, or using custom built protocol buffers compiler and gRPC plugin.

Name	Synopsis
PROTOBUF_TOOLS_OS	Operating system version of the tools to use: linux, macosx, or windows
PROTOBUF_TOOLS_CPU	CPU architecture version of the tools to use: x86, x64, or arm64
PROTOBUF_PROTOC	Full path to the protocol buffers compiler
GRPC_PROTOC_PLUGIN	Full path to the grpc_csharp_plugin

For example, to use a custom built protoc compiler and grpc_csharp_plugin:

export PROTOBUF_PROTOC=$my_custom_build/protoc
export GRPC_PROTOC_PLUGIN=$my_custom_build/grpc_csharp_plugin
dotnet build myproject.csproj

MSBuild Properties

You can set some Properties in your project file or on the MSBuild command line. The following properties change the behavior of Grpc.Tools:

Name	Synopsis
Protobuf_ToolsOs	Same as PROTOBUF_TOOLS_OS environment variable
Protobuf_ToolsCpu	Same as PROTOBUF_TOOLS_CPU environment variable
Protobuf_ProtocFullPath	Same as PROTOBUF_PROTOC environment variable
gRPC_PluginFullPath	Same as GRPC_PROTOC_PLUGIN environment variable
Protobuf_NoWarnMissingExpected	Default: false. If true then no warnings are given if expected files not generated. See example below for an explanation.
Protobuf_OutputPath	Default: IntermediateOutputPath - ususally the obj directory. Sets the default value for OutputDir on <Protobuf> items.
EnableDefaultProtobufItems	Default: false. If true then .proto files under the project are automatically included without the need to specify any <Protobuf> items.
Protobuf_StandardImportsPath	The path for protobuf's well known types included in the NuGet package. It is automcatically passed to protoc via the -I/--proto_path option.

Scenarios and Examples

For other examples see also the .csproj files in the examples in GitHub:

• grpc-dotnet examples
• Grpc.Core examples

Quick links to the examples below:

• ProtoRoot - Common root for one or more .proto files
• AdditionalImportDirs - Setting location of imported .proto files
• GrpcServices - Generating gRPC services and protocol buffers messages
• Automatically including .proto files
• Generate proto and gRPC C# sources from .proto files (no C# compile)
• Visual Studio: setting per-file .proto file options
• Bypassing Grpc.Tools to run the protocol buffers compiler explicitly

---

ProtoRoot - Common root for one or more .proto files

ProtoRoot specifies a common directory that is an ancestor for a set of .proto files.

It has two purposes:

• working out relative directories to preserve the structure when generating .cs files
• adding a directory to be searched for imported .proto files

These are explained in an example below.

For .proto files under the project directory ProtoRoot is by default set to .. It can also be explicitly set.

For .proto files outside of the project the value is set to the file's containing directory name. If you include a subtree of .proto files then you must set ProtoRoot to give the parent of the directory tree.

In either case if you are importing a .proto file from within another file then you should set ProtoRoot so that the import paths can be found. (See also AdditionalImportDirs below.)

Generated files in the output directory will have the same directory structure as the .proto files under ProtoRoot.

By default the output directory for generated files is obj\CONFIGURATION\FRAMEWORK\ (e.g. obj\Debug\net6.0\) unless OutputDir or GrpcOutputDir are specified.

Example use of ProtoRoot

Specifying:

<Protobuf Include="Protos\Services\**\*.proto"
          ProtoRoot="Protos" />
<Protobuf Include="Protos\Messages\**\*.proto"
          ProtoRoot="Protos"
          GrpcServices="None" />
<Protobuf Include="..\OutsideProjectProtos\**\*.proto"
          ProtoRoot="..\OutsideProjectProtos" />

for files:

	ProjectFolder\Protos\Services\v1\hello.proto
	ProjectFolder\Protos\Services\v2\hello.proto
	ProjectFolder\Protos\Messages\v1\message.proto
	..\OutsideProjectProtos\MyApi\alpha.proto
	..\OutsideProjectProtos\MyApi\beta.proto

will generate files:

  ProjectFolder\obj\Debug\net6.0\Services\v1\Hello.cs
  ProjectFolder\obj\Debug\net6.0\Services\v1\HelloGrpc.cs
  ProjectFolder\obj\Debug\net6.0\Services\v2\Hello.cs
  ProjectFolder\obj\Debug\net6.0\Services\v2\HelloGrpc.cs
  ProjectFolder\obj\Debug\net6.0\Messages\v1\Message.cs
  ProjectFolder\obj\Debug\net6.0\MyApi\Alpha.cs
  ProjectFolder\obj\Debug\net6.0\MyApi\AlphaGrpc.cs
  ProjectFolder\obj\Debug\net6.0\MyApi\Beta.cs
  ProjectFolder\obj\Debug\net6.0\MyApi\BetaGrpc.cs

Things to notes:

• the directory structures under ProjectFolder\Protos\ and ..\OutsideProjectProtos\ are mirrored in the output directory.
• the import search paths passed to protoc via -I/--proto_path option will include ProjectFolder\Protos and ..\OutsideProjectProtos

---

AdditionalImportDirs - Setting location of imported .proto files

In addition to specifying ProtoRoot other import directories can be specified for directories to search when importing .proto files by specifying AdditionalImportDirs and provide a list of directories. The directories are searched in the order given.

You would use this when you want to import .proto files that you don't need to separately compile as they are only used in import statements. E.g.:

  <Protobuf Include="protos/*.proto"
            ProtoRoot="protos"
            AdditionalImportDirs="/folder/protos/mytypes/;/another/folder/"
      ... />

Note: The path for protobuf's well known types is automatically included. E.g. the import below will work without having to explicity specifying the path in AdditionalImportDirs:

import "google/protobuf/wrappers.proto";

---

GrpcServices - Generating gRPC services and protocol buffers messages

The protocol buffers files (.proto files) define both the service interface and the structure of the payload messages.

Two .cs file can be generated from a .proto file. For example, if the .proto file is myfile.proto then the two possible files are:

• Myfile.cs - contains the generated code for protocol buffers messages
• MyfileGrpc.cs - contains the generated code for gRPC client and/or server

When a .proto file contains service definitions the protocol buffers compiler calls the gRPC plugin to generate gRPC client and/or server stub code. Whether or not the *Grpc.cs file is generated and what it contains is controlled by the GrpcServices metadata on the <Protobuf> item.

• GrpcServices="Both" (the default) - Myfile.cs and MyfileGrpc.cs generated
• GrpcServices="None" - just Myfile.cs generated
• GrpcServices="Client" - Myfile.cs and MyfileGrpc.cs (just client code)
• GrpcServices="Server" - Myfile.cs and MyfileGrpc.cs (just server code)

However when a .proto does not file contains any service definitions but only contains message definitions then an empty (zero length) MyfileGrpc.cs may still be created by Grpc.Tools unless the .proto file is specified with GrpcServices="None" in the project file.

This is because Grpc.Tools has no way of knowing in advanced of running the protocol buffers compiler whether a .proto file has a service clause. It creates the empty files as a marker for incremental builds so that the .proto files are not unnecessarily recompiled. Empty files are not a problem on a small project but you may wish to avoid them on a larger project.

Therefore it is better to explicitly mark files with the correct GrpcServices metadata if you can. For example:

<ItemGroup>
  <Protobuf Include="**/*.proto" GrpcServices="None" />
  <Protobuf Update="**/hello/*.proto;**/bye/*.proto" GrpcServices="Both" />
</ItemGroup>

In the above example all .proto files are compiled with GrpcServices="None", except for .proto files in subdirectories on any tree level named hello and bye, which will take GrpcServices="Both". Note the use of the Update attribute instead of Include - otherwise the files would be added twice.

Another example would be the use of globbing if your service .proto files are named according to a pattern, for example *_services.proto. In this case the Update attribute can be written as Update="**/*_service.proto" to set the attribute GrpcServices="Both" only on these files.

Seeing a warning about a missing expected file

You will see the warning message:

Some expected protoc outputs were not generated

if all these are true:

• the location for the generated files is configured to a directory outside of the project, e.g. OutputDir="..\outside-project\"
• *Grpc.cs files have not been created because the .proto file does not contain a service definintion
• you have not specified GrpcServices="None"

This is because Grpc.Tools only creates empty *Grpc.cs files in directories within the project (such as the intermediate obj directory). Empty files are not created outside of the project directory so as not to pollute non-project directories.

This warning can be suppressed by setting the MSBuild property:

<PropertyGroup>
  <Protobuf_NoWarnMissingExpected>true</Protobuf_NoWarnMissingExpected>
</PropertyGroup>

however it is better to set GrpcServices="None" on the .proto files affected to avoid unnecessary rebuilds.

---

Automatically including .proto files

For SDK projects it is possible to automatically include .proto files found in the project directory or sub-directories, without having to specify them with a <Protobuf> item. To do this the property EnableDefaultProtobufItems has be set to true in the project file or on the MSBuild command line.

It is recommended that you do not rely on automatic inclusion of .proto files except for the simplest of projects since it does not allow you to control other settings such as GrpcServices.

By default EnableDefaultProtobufItems is not set and <Protobuf> items must be included in the project for the .proto files to be compiled.

---

Generate proto and gRPC C# sources from .proto files (no C# compile)

If you just want to generate the C# sources from .proto files without compiling the C# files (e.g. for use in other projects) then you can do something similar to this to a .csproj file:

<ItemGroup>
 <Protobuf Include="**/*.proto"
     OutputDir="%(RelativeDir)" CompileOutputs="false"  />
</ItemGroup>

• Include tells the build system to recursively examine project directory and its subdirectories (**) include all files matching the wildcard *.proto.
• OutputDir="%(RelativeDir)" makes the output directory for each .cs file to be same as the corresponding .proto directory.
• CompileOutputs="false" prevents compiling the generated files into an assembly.

Note that an empty assembly is still generated which can be ignored.

NOTE: To start with an empty project to add your .proto files to you can do the following at a command prompt:

dotnet new classlib
rm *.cs              # remove .cs files - for Windows the command is: del *.cs /y
dotnet add package Grpc.Tools

---

Visual Studio: setting per-file .proto file options

In Visual Studio it is possible to set some frequently used per-file options on .proto files without editing the .csproj file directly. However editing the .csproj gives you more flexibilty.

“dotnet SDK” projects

For a “dotnet SDK” project, you have more control of some frequently used options. You may need to open and close Visual Studio for this form to appear in the properties window after adding a reference to Grpc.Tools package:

You can also change options of multiple files at once by selecting them in the Project Explorer together.

“classic” projects

For a “classic” project, you can only add .proto files with all options set to default. Click on the “show all files” button, add files to project, then change file type of the .proto files to “Protobuf” in the Properties window drop-down. This menu item will appear after you import the Grpc.Tools package:

---

Bypassing Grpc.Tools to run the protocol buffers compiler explicitly

It is possible to bypass all the build logic in Grpc.Tools and run the protocol buffers compiler explicitly in your project file, and just use the Grpc.Tools as a means of getting the compiler. This is not recommended but there may be situations where you want to do this.

You can use the following Properties:

• Protobuf_ProtocFullPath points to the full path and filename of protoc executable, e.g. "...\.nuget\packages\grpc.tools\2.51.0\build\native\bin\windows\protoc.exe"

• gRPC_PluginFullPath points to the full path and filename of gRPC plugin, e.g. "...\.nuget\packages\grpc.tools\2.51.0\build\native\bin\windows\grpc_csharp_plugin.exe"

• Protobuf_StandardImportsPath points to the standard proto import directory, e.g. "...\.nuget\packages\grpc.tools\2.51.0\build\native\include". This is the directory where a declaration such as import "google/protobuf/wrappers.proto"; in a proto file would find its target.

then in your project file:

  <Target Name="MyProtoCompile">
    <PropertyGroup>
      <ProtoCCommand>$(Protobuf_ProtocFullPath) --plugin=protoc-gen-grpc=$(gRPC_PluginFullPath)  -I $(Protobuf_StandardImportsPath) ....rest of your command.... </ProtoCCommand>
    </PropertyGroup>
    <Message Importance="high" Text="$(ProtoCCommand)" />
    <Exec Command="$(ProtoCCommand)" />
  </Target>

Do not include any <Protobuf> items in the project file as that will invoke the Grpc.Tools build and your files will be compiled twice.

---

See also

gRPC project documentation:

• gRPC for .NET
• gRPC C# (legacy implementation using gRPC Core library)
• Grpc.Tools internals - implementation notes for how Grpc.Tools works

Microsoft documentation:

• Microsoft: Overview for gRPC on .NET
• Microsoft: C# Tooling support for .proto files